Loading...
You are here:  Home  >  Mutual Fund  >  Current Article

Fixed Deposit Vs Debt Mutual Funds

By   /   June 5, 2013  /   2 Comments

 

FD Vs FMPFixed Maturity Plans(FMPs) are closed-end debt funds that are quite popular and useful. These FMPs, as they are called, are launched on a specific date for a specific period that can range from 1 month to 5 years.

FMPs are an excellent alternative to bank fixed deposits. They generally offer higher returns, especially because they are much more tax-efficient. This is because FMPs are taxed as capital gains while bank FDs are just added to the investors’ normal income.

 

Following examples will help you better understand how it works:

Ex.1

Say you deposited Rs.1,00,000 in bank Fixed Deposit on 10th November 2010. Interest Rate be 9% per annum. Interest accumulated at the end of 1 year will be 1,00,000*9% = Rs.9,000.

Hold on !!! Rs.9,000 is not your net profit…how can you forget Tax. So net profit as per your tax bracket will be as follows;

Taxation of FD’s:

Note: Interest from Bank FD’s is added to your income & taxed accordingly.

No. Profit Before Tax Tax Bracket Profit After Tax
1. 9,000 30.9% 6219
2. 9,000 20.6% 7146
3. 9,000 10.3% 8073

 

To know more about how to calculate tax read my Article: How To Calculate Tax

Instead of investing in Bank Fixed Deposit if you invest in a Debt Mutual Fund (funds investing in government securities & bonds with very less or no exposure to equity), you will get indexation benefit resulting in very less or at times no tax payment.

 

Ex.2

Say you deposited Rs.1,00,000 in Mutual Fund “Fixed Maturity 370 days Plan” on 28th March 2011.

About Fixed Maturity Plan (FMP’s):

– Debt Mutual Fund

– Maturity Period: 370 Days

– Rate of Interest: Similar to prevailing Interest rate of Bank FD’s maturing in one year.

So at 9% rate of Interest, your MF will mature on 2nd April 2012 & will fetch you approximately Rs.9,000.

Note: 9% rate is not fixed, so maturity amount is taken as approx. Though most of the times returns from FMP’s are in line with returns from Bank FD’s.

 

Taxation Of Mutual Funds:

Debt Mutual Funds are taxed @ 10.3% without Indexation & 20.6% with Indexation. In this case since MF is sold after 365 days, it will be termed as Long Term Capital Asset. To know more about Long Term Capital Asset & Indexation, read my article: Indexation.

Case1.

Without Indexation

1. Buying Price Rs.1,00,000
2. Selling Price Rs.1,09,000
3. Profit Buying Price – Selling Price = 9,000
4. Tax on Debt MF 10.3% without Indexation
5. Tax Amount 9,000*10.3% = Rs.927
6. Profit After Tax 9,000 – 927 = Rs.8073

 

Note: No matter in which tax bracket you are, tax on long term capital gain from mutual fund will be taxed @ 10.3% (Without Indexation)

Case 2.

With Indexation

1. CII: 2010-11 711
2. CII: 2012-13 852
3. Purchase Price Rs.1,00,000
4. Indexed Purchase Price 1,00,000*(852/711) = 1,19,831
5. Selling Price 1,09,000
6. Profit Selling Price – Indexed Purchase Price = ( -10,831 )
7. Tax On Debt Mutual Fund 20.6% with Indexation
8. Tax Amount Nil, as tax is calculated on profit & with Indexation profit comes to be zero.
9. Profit After Tax 9,000

Since in Case2. (With Indexation) we need not to pay tax, hence we will choose the Indexation method.

 

Conclusion: Generally retail investors do not know about Debt MF & they deposit their money in bank FDs & end up paying tax as per their tax slab. So it’s better to Invest in Debt Mutual Fund than Bank FDs.

 

Recommended Articles For You:

1. Financial Kundali For You

2. All About Indexation

3. How To Calculate Tax.

4. Taxation Of Mutual Funds

 

 

(16334)

    Print       Email

About the author

Hi My name is Hari Om Tripathi. I am an engineer by chance & a Personal Financial Planner by choice. Currently residing in Kanpur & writing full time for Financial Kundali. In case you have any query about Personal Financial Planning such a buying a MF or ULIP, going for a life insurance plan or a term plan, to surrender your policy or not or any other questions related to your Personal Financial Planning, write to me at financialkundali@gmail.com

Leave a Reply

You might also like...

Is Investing in Mutual Fund through SIP fully Safe !

Read More →